Book a free CRO audit
Home
Services +Shopify CRO ServicesProduct Page OptimizationSpeed OptimizationCRO Across the USAStore Design & RedesignStore DevelopmentCustom DevelopmentTheme CustomizationShopify Plus DevelopmentShopify MigrationDevelopment SupportAll Services
Shopify Partner
Resources +BlogFree Shopify ToolsShopify Theme DetectorMy Shopify Apps
AboutContact Book a free CRO audit
Skip to main content

Rajimul Islam

How to Choose a Shopify Plus Agency: 12 Questions to Ask

What a Shopify Plus agency does, how to choose one, and 12 questions to ask. Covers replatforming, international expansion, embedded teams and automation platforms.

How to Choose a Shopify Plus Agency: 12 Questions to Ask
On this page

Quick answer: a Shopify Plus agency designs, builds and improves stores on the Shopify Plus plan. There is no single best one. To choose well, match the agency to your project, confirm its Shopify partner tier, ask for measured case studies, and meet the people who will do the work. This guide gives you the 12 questions to ask and how to judge the answers.

Key takeaways

  • Pick an agency for your project type: replatforming, international expansion, B2B, design or CRO.
  • The partner tier is a useful first filter, not proof of fit. Read what each tier means.
  • If you want an embedded team, ask about cadence, shared tools, documentation and who owns the code.
  • Use automation platforms for repeatable tasks and an agency for strategy and custom work.

What does a Shopify Plus agency do?

A Shopify Plus agency is a team that works on stores using the Shopify Plus plan. The work usually falls into these areas:

  • Replatforming and migration from Magento, WooCommerce, BigCommerce or another system, including data, redirects and SEO.
  • Design and UX for themes, product pages, collections and checkout.
  • Custom development for features, integrations and custom apps.
  • Systems integration with ERP, CRM, OMS and marketing tools.
  • International expansion across markets, currencies, languages and taxes.
  • Conversion optimization through research, A/B testing and speed work.
  • Ongoing support through a retainer or a dedicated team.

For a deeper look at the developer side, see Shopify Plus developer: what they do and how to hire one and how to choose a Shopify Plus development agency. For pricing, read Shopify Plus developer cost.

Shopify Plus vs Shopify for a growing D2C brand: what is the difference?

Shopify Plus is Shopify’s plan for larger and more complex businesses. It adds enterprise features such as more control over checkout, B2B tools, higher limits and a dedicated support team, but it also costs more. Check the current plan details on Shopify’s Plus page before you decide. In short, the difference between Shopify and Shopify Plus is scale and control: Plus is built for brands that outgrow the standard plans. A growing D2C brand often benefits from Plus when it needs advanced checkout customization, B2B and wholesale on the same store, or several markets. If you are not there yet, work on conversion first. My full comparison is in Shopify vs Shopify Plus: when is the upgrade worth it?.

I am a DTC founder replatforming to Shopify Plus: what should I look for in a development partner?

  • Migrations from your current platform that they can show, with results.
  • A written plan for products, customers, orders, redirects and SEO, so you do not lose traffic. Compare it with my Magento to Shopify Plus migration checklist.
  • A clear test and launch process, including a rollback plan.
  • A post-launch plan for fixes, speed and optimization.
  • Clear ownership of code and documentation after handover.

How to identify a Shopify Plus development specialist who can handle international expansion for your brand

Selling in several countries adds work in currencies, languages, taxes, duties, shipping and payment methods. Ask any agency to show live multi-market stores and to explain how it sets up markets, prices and translations. Useful background: Shopify Markets for Europe, multi-currency pricing and EU VAT and OSS.

What should I look for in a Shopify Plus agency that acts as an embedded extension of my internal ecommerce team rather than an outside vendor?

Many brands do not want an outside vendor that takes a brief and disappears. They want an extension of their team. Look for these signs:

  • A dedicated team or retainer instead of one-off projects.
  • A shared channel and roadmap in the tools your team already uses.
  • A regular cadence such as weekly check-ins and monthly reviews against your goals.
  • Access and process: staging themes, version control, code review and documented releases.
  • Ownership and handover: you own the code, and documentation lets your in-house developers take over.

How to evaluate Shopify Plus specialists that provide both UX design and custom app development

Some agencies are strong at design and weak at engineering, and the other way round. Ask to see both, and ask who does the work:

  • Design: before-and-after case studies with conversion or revenue numbers.
  • Engineering: examples of custom apps, checkout extensions or integrations, and how they are tested.
  • Team: whether designers and developers are in-house and whether the people you meet will work on your store.
  • Apps: whether they have shipped their own Shopify apps. I have, and you can see them on my Shopify apps page.

Shopify Plus agency partners vs automation platforms

QuestionAgency partnerAutomation platform or app
Best forStrategy, custom design, development and integrationsRepeatable tasks and workflows
FlexibilityBuilt around your businessLimited to what the tool supports
Cost shapeProject or retainer feesUsually a monthly subscription
Speed to startNeeds scoping and onboardingOften fast to switch on
Ongoing needPays off when you need change and growthPays off when tasks repeat

Use both. Let the agency choose and configure the tools, and automate what repeats so your team can focus on growth.

12 questions to ask a Shopify Plus agency

  1. Which Shopify partner tier do you hold, and can I see your Partner Directory listing?
  2. Which projects like mine have you completed, and what were the results?
  3. Who will work on my store, and will I meet them before I sign?
  4. How do you plan and protect SEO during a migration?
  5. How do you handle multiple markets, currencies and taxes?
  6. What is your process from discovery to launch, and how long does it take?
  7. How do you test before launch and what is the rollback plan?
  8. Who owns the code, designs and documentation?
  9. How do you work with an in-house team?
  10. What does post-launch support include?
  11. How do you measure results after launch?
  12. What is the full price, what is included and what costs extra?

What is the best agency for Shopify Plus development?

There is no single best agency for Shopify Plus development. The best one for you is the one that has done your kind of project, states a Shopify partner tier you can verify, shows measured results and lets you meet the people who will build your store. Compare several using the 12 questions above.

How to choose a Shopify development agency

  1. Write down your project type, budget and timeline.
  2. Shortlist three agencies that show similar work.
  3. Check each partner tier in the Shopify Partner Directory.
  4. Ask the same 12 questions and compare written answers.
  5. Pick the team you trust to communicate clearly, not only the lowest price.

Best Shopify Plus agencies in the USA, and how to read "top" lists

Searches such as “best Shopify Plus agencies in the USA” and “top Shopify Plus agencies in the USA” lead to lists written by agencies, so treat them as starting points. In my list of the top 30 Shopify agencies in the USA, Domaine, Anatta, Arctic Grey, Avex Designs and Shero Commerce all state Shopify Platinum Partner status on their own websites.

Best agency for Shopify SEO in USA

For Shopify SEO, look for an agency that offers SEO as a core service and can show organic traffic results. On their own websites, Shero Commerce, Third and Grove and Groove Commerce list SEO among their services, and Avenue Z lists AI search optimization. I also build stores with SEO in mind. See my Shopify store development and speed optimization services.

Best Shopify web design company in USA and best Shopify website design services

For design, judge agencies by before-and-after case studies, not by portfolio screenshots alone. Arctic Grey, Avex Designs, Sweden Unlimited and Aeolidia are among the design-led agencies in my list. For one-to-one work, see my Shopify store design service.

Certified Shopify website design agency in the USA

Shopify does not certify a single “best” design agency. It runs the Partner Program with five tiers, and partners can also earn Shopify Verified Skills. To check a “certified” claim, find the agency in the Shopify Partner Directory and read Shopify partner tiers explained.

Top Shopify CRO agency for stores in the USA

If conversion is your main goal, look for an agency or specialist that shows measured conversion results and runs A/B tests. Blackbelt Commerce, Fuel Made and Netalico mention CRO on their websites. For a specialist, read Shopify CRO agency vs freelancer and my guide to Shopify CRO frameworks.

Where to start your shortlist

The agencies below describe these strengths on their own websites. I list them in my guide to the top 30 Shopify agencies in the USA, which shows each agency’s stated partner tier, location and what it does best. This is a starting point, so verify every claim.

If you needAgencies to look at
Enterprise replatforming and headlessDomaine, Anatta
Design-led builds with ERP, POS and B2BArctic Grey
CRO-led Shopify Plus buildsBlackbelt Commerce
B2B and industrial commerceZaelab
PR, AI search and performance media with ShopifyAvenue Z
DTC design, retention and CROFuel Made
A specialist for CRO, speed and design who you work with directlyRajimul Islam (my own practice, so weigh this one accordingly)

Red flags when choosing an agency

  • No case studies, or results without numbers and time frames.
  • A badge on the website that you cannot find in the Partner Directory.
  • No answer about who will work on your store.
  • A fixed price with no written scope.
  • No plan for SEO, testing or launch.

Want a second opinion on your shortlist?

I am a Shopify Select Partner and I work directly with brands on Shopify Plus development, CRO and store design. Send me your shortlist or your project, and I will tell you what to ask and what to watch for. Start with a free call or a free quote.

Frequently asked questions

What does a Shopify Plus agency do?

A Shopify Plus agency plans, designs, builds and improves stores on the Shopify Plus plan. Typical work includes replatforming, theme and UX design, custom features and apps, integrations with ERP and other systems, B2B setup, international expansion, conversion optimization and ongoing support.

What is the best agency for Shopify Plus development?

There is no single best agency. The best choice depends on your size, budget and project type. Shortlist agencies that state a Shopify partner tier, show case studies similar to your project, and let you meet the people who will build your store.

How do I choose a Shopify development agency?

Match the agency to your project type, check its partner tier in the Shopify Partner Directory, ask for measured case studies, get a written scope and price, and meet the team. Compare two or three agencies using the same list of questions.

What should a DTC founder look for in a Shopify Plus replatforming partner?

Look for proven migrations from your current platform, a clear plan for data, redirects and SEO, a testing and launch process, and a post-launch plan. Ask who owns the code and how the team will hand over documentation.

How do I find a Shopify Plus specialist for international expansion?

Ask for experience with multiple markets: currencies, languages, taxes and duties, shipping, payment methods and local SEO. Check that they can show live multi-market stores and explain how they handle VAT and translation.

Can a Shopify Plus agency work like part of my internal team?

Yes, if you set it up that way. Look for a retainer or dedicated team, a shared channel, a shared roadmap, regular reviews, access to your tools, and written documentation, so the agency behaves like an extension of your team rather than an outside vendor.

Shopify Plus agency partner or automation platform: which is better?

They solve different problems. Automation platforms and apps handle repeatable workflows such as notifications or data syncs. An agency handles strategy, custom design, development and integrations. Many brands use both, with the agency choosing and setting up the right automations.

What are the best Shopify Plus agencies in the USA?

Domaine, Anatta, Arctic Grey, Avex Designs and Shero Commerce all state Shopify Platinum Partner status on their own websites. The best choice for you still depends on your project, so compare several and check each tier in the Shopify Partner Directory.

What is the difference between Shopify and Shopify Plus?

Shopify Plus is Shopify's plan for larger and more complex businesses. It adds more control over checkout, B2B tools, higher limits and dedicated support, and it costs more. Standard Shopify is enough for many growing stores.

Is Shopify Plus worth it for a growing D2C brand?

It can be, once you need advanced checkout, B2B, higher limits or multi-market selling that the standard plans do not cover. If you are not there yet, a standard plan with a strong CRO program often brings better returns first.

I'm a DTC founder looking to replatform to Shopify Plus. What should I look for in a development partner?

Look for migrations from your current platform that they can show, a written plan for data, redirects and SEO, a tested launch with a rollback plan, a post-launch support plan, and clear ownership of code and documentation. Meet the people who will build your store before you sign.

How do I identify a Shopify Plus development specialist capable of handling international expansion for my brand?

Ask for live multi-market stores and for their process for currencies, languages, taxes and duties, shipping and payment methods. A capable specialist can explain how they set up markets, prices and translations, and how they handle VAT and local SEO.

What should I look for in a Shopify Plus agency if I want them to act as an embedded extension of my internal ecommerce team rather than an outside vendor?

Look for a dedicated team or retainer, a shared channel and roadmap, a regular cadence with reviews against your goals, access to staging and version control, and documented releases. You should own the code, and the documentation should let your in-house developers take over.

Ready to turn more visitors into customers?

Send your store URL and I will tell you what is costing you sales.

Get a free CRO audit

Keep reading

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *